Long time readers know I am a huge Windows Mobile 10 fan. I’ve had a Windows Phone/Mobile device for nearly four years and, prior to that, I had a Windows Mobile 5 device (a Motorola Q) waaaay back in 2008. Needless to say, I like Microsoft’s mobile operating systems. I had an Android phone in 2011 and then got an iPhone 4 when Sprint started carrying them. I NEVER liked that Android phone or the OS itself. I tended to crash and always told me I had filled up its storage even when there were gigabytes left on the SD card. It was slow too, much slower than my Palm Pre, Moto Q or that iPhone. Android was terrible. I said good bye and that was that.
Well, fast forward a few years and my beloved Windows Mobile 10 is, sadly, being left behind by its own creator. It never caught on with the public or with business, even with the hooks that business wanted. Sadly, it was an iOS and Android world.
Earlier this year, I spent a ton of money on an Alcatel Idol 4s with Windows Mobile 10. It is a fantastic phone, but developed an audio issue…I couldn’t hear phone calls unless on speaker phone. Apps I was using were being abandoned. I decided I needed to byte the bullet and move on. I can still use the phone, as a desktop device due to Continuum. But, what would replace such a capable phone and OS?
I read about Samsung’s Galaxy S7. Seems like a great device. But, then I discovered the S8 was out and was even more capable. So…I got one. Discounting the awful experience I had getting the phone (T-Mobile is far worse, customer service wise, than any other carrier…but, that is another story) the transition from Win Mo 10 to Android Nougat was much easier than I had thought it would be. The first thing I did was to Microsoft my phone. I installed the Arrow launcher, install Office, install Cortana, setup OneDrive, install Bing, set Bing as my default search engine, made sure the fluffy Google crap was off or uninstalled and installed SwiftKey. I tried some of the Win Mo 10 like launchers, but, ultimately, went to Arrow and its more Androidy look. The Win Mo 10 Launchers work well, but, I decided to make Arrow my default as it is developed and supported by MS and it works very well. No crashes.
So, how do I like the S8?
Well, it is superb. Fast, shiny, feels good and looks great. It is a tad more narrow than I would prefer, but that is a small thing and easily overlooked. Battery life is decent, but I think older Alcatel Fierce XL had better battery life. The curved, infinity screen is fine, but I am not sure I like the infinity screen: I inevitably do something I didn’t want to do. I do not think the curved sides are all that useful either. I’ve not seen anything that really utilizes them.
The fit and finish is superb. This phone feels like it is expensive and looks like it as well. Of course, it is expensive, around $600 to $800 (US). I really like the hardware. It is fantastic.
What about Android?
Well, I still hate Android, just not as much. I could grow to like it. In time. Maybe.
What’s good about Android?
This is a bit hard as there are certain things I really like, but I am not sure they are actually Android or Samsung developed. For instance, I like the softkey bar. home button, task button and back button are easily accessible and get out of the way when not needed. I am not sure if this is stock Android or Samsung. It’s nice, though. I also like skinning ability, but, again, I see more Samsung than Android. I know Android can do this, just not sure how much is one or the other. Android also seems to be more stable than I recall. The notification system is fantastic, but a pain in the rear as well. I think, overall, Android has come a very long way. BUT…it is still ANDROID and not Windows Mobile and therein lies most of my problems with it.
What’s bad about Android?
It is not Windows Mobile 10. Windows Mobile 10 had its live tiles, was so much easier to navigate and Edge has turned into an excellent mobile browser. Integrated Cortana worked well. Android is none of this. ‘OK, Google’ is a joke. The deafness of the launcher screens, the navigation is not very intuitive and the overall appearance of Android-while better than in the past-still has a long way to go. Material Design seems to be missing and Google Services do not seem to be any better than those from Microsoft or–gasp–Apple. Except for one big exception.
So, what’s the exception?
Google Photos is top notch. I really like this service. To steal a saying from Apple…it just works. It works when I do not ask it to do so. And, the results are very impressive. I thought Microsoft Photos, with the new video storyteller, was going to be best in class. I was wrong. Microsoft’s new Photo additions are great, but this service is even better. Try it. You. Will. LOVE IT.
So, I am out of the Windows Mobile ecosystem, probably for good. I don’t know how long I will be an Android user, but, if things continue the way they are, I don’t see myself going anywhere else for a very long time.