I’ve been using the Fierce XL with Windows Mobile 10 for almost a month now. I bought the phone from T-Mobile to temporarily replace my now ailing Lumia Icon from Verizon. As Verizon no longer considers Windows a viable platform for them, I went to T-Mobile who is still friendly toward the mobile operating system.
The Fierce XL from Alcatel OneTouch was $140 (US) to buy out right. No contract and a $40 a month plan made it a nice deal. So, how does it compare to my old Icon?
Well, not very well. And that is just fine. The Icon was a ‘flagship’ , that is, it was considered a premium phone with premium features. The Fierce XL is not. It does, however, have some features that were, previously, a premium feature, like 2GB of RAM and a large HD display. It also came with Windows Mobile 10. So, it is not quite a slouch but no high end phone either. I knew this going in.
In most respects, it is a good device. Not as fast as the Icon, not as slow as my even older Lumia 521 or iPhone 4. In terms of performance, it is closer to an iPhone 5. The 2GB of RAM helps a lot. The OS is fluid, but does hiccup once in a while. I am running a ‘Redstone 1’ insider build, so there are OS issues, but they are the result of running beta code. However, that code does bring out features that were not in the shipping release of Windows Mobile 10, like a quasi Continuum feature. More on that in a bit.
The camera is, perhaps, the weakest point of the device. The rear camera is only eight megapixels and has poor low light ability. The images are not very crisp and color tends to be more on the muted side of things. Coming from my Icon, it is a huge let down. Again, I was aware of this when I got the phone, but it was still a big let down. Almost enough to take the phone back to T-Mobile, but, alas, my poor Icon’s battery is on life support. As is the body of the phone.
Which brings me to the best and worst aspect of the Fierce XL: it’s body is all plastic. The back is a funky shade of blue that has grown on me, but is also now covered up by an overpriced rubbery shell that the salesguy sold me at T-Mobile. The plastic case looks cheap and feels cheap, but it likely will not break or dent, like the Icon’s all metal body did. I don’t mind the plastic all that much, but it does feel cheap, which makes me think I would not like it on, say, the Lumia 950.
Overall, the hardware-except for the camera-is decent. Performance is good, considering the price. While it feels cheap, the build quality is quite good.
As I mentioned earlier, the latest Windows 10 insider builds unlock a nice Continuum feature. To use it, both the phone and the computer must be running the latest builds of Windows 10 Insider (the ‘Redstone 1’ builds) as the feature needs the PC to have the plumbing for Continuum. So, what does it do? Well, it lets you, via the ‘connect’ feature on the device, to allow the phone’s screen to be shown on the PC’s monitor and allows the PC’s keyboard and mouse be recognized by the phone. This lets you use the phone as if it were the computer. The difference, though, between this and the ‘real’ continuum is that you cannot do something else on the phone while using Continuum, and it does not scale the phone’s screen to fit the monitor. It is the same as the old ‘connect’ or project my screen feature. It is a nice feature, though one that I don’t see myself using all that much. Perhaps I will if I use my phone at my job to take notes or start work on a document or spreadsheet. Though, I generally just save to my OneDrive and use my PC and its apps. So, while this is cool and nice, and all that, I’m not sure that I’d use it all that much.
Windows 10 runs very well on this hardware and gives me hope that Alcatel Onetouch will bring some of its better hardware to Windows Mobile, like the Idol 3. It also gives me hope that other manufacturers will follow. Indeed, HP, Acer and HTC all have or will have Windows Mobile devices out very soon, if not now.
The Fierce XL with Windows 10 is available from T-Mobile for $139.95.